Huricane Juan
Toronto Star
  • Jian Ghomeshi: 8 women accuse former CBC host of violence, sexual abuse or harassment

    Eight women from across Canada now accuse former CBC host Jian Ghomeshi of abusive behaviour ranging from allegations of beating and choking without consent, to workplace sexual harassment.

    The allegations the Star is probing range from 2002 to the present.

    One of the women, popular Canadian television actor Lucy DeCoutere, has agreed to be identified. DeCoutere, who plays Lucy on Trailer Park Boys , recalls an incident in 2003 when she alleges Ghomeshi, without warning or consent, choked her to the point she could not breathe and then slapped her hard three times on the side of her head.

    ?He did not ask if I was into it. It was never a question. It was shocking to me. The men I have spent time with are loving people,? said DeCoutere, who, when she is not acting on the television show, is a captain in the Royal Canadian Air Force in New Brunswick.

    Ghomeshi, 47, was fired Sunday from his job as host of Q , a flagship radio show of the publicly funded broadcaster. Ghomeshi has alleged in a lawsuit filed the next day that CBC made a ?moral judgment? that his practice of a bondage-sadism sex life was wrong. He is suing the CBC for $55 million for defamation and breach of trust and the corporation has said it will ?vigorously? defend itself against Ghomeshi?s lawsuit.

    The Star has presented Ghomeshi, his lawyers and his public relations staff with the allegations in this story and they have yet to respond.

    He met some of the women during his 2012 tour to promote 1982 , his best- selling memoir about a year in high school in Thornhill. Others he met at film festivals, at music or CBC events, or at the CBC workplace.

    Two of the women who allege they were physically assaulted also say that before the alleged assaults in his home he introduced them to Big Ears Teddy, a stuffed bear, and he turned the bear around just before he slapped or choked them, saying that ?Big Ears Teddy shouldn?t see this.?

    One of the new women to come forward is a woman in her mid-20s who was a CBC producer in Montreal who dreamed of being on Q . He met her at one of his book signings. Ghomeshi allegedly took her to his hotel room, threw her against the wall and was very ?forceful? with her. She said she performed oral sex ?to get out of there.? The woman, who still works in the media but not at CBC, said she decided not to complain about his behaviour because she feared he was too powerful.

    ?I felt like Jian was CBC god,? she told the Star in an interview. She is the second CBC woman to come forward with allegations of sexual harassment by Ghomeshi. The CBC has announced they are investigating the first case, where Ghomeshi allegedly told a CBC staffer he wanted to ?hate f---? her.

    Generally, the stories the women have told the Star describe a man obsessed with his image and power, and someone who they say has little or no respect for barriers.

    Over the course of the Star?s investigation, women who say they were victimized said they did not feel comfortable putting their name to the allegations. Some say they feared retaliation from Ghomeshi, online harassment and a negative impact on their careers.

    DeCoutere said it was time for someone to speak publicly about the matter.

    She first met Ghomeshi at a barbecue at a Banff television festival in 2003. They chatted and, in time, she visited Toronto and they had dinner at a restaurant on the Danforth. She recalls him telling her how famous he was and ?how lucky you are to be with me.? They went back to his house in Riverdale. DeCoutere said they began making out and then she alleges he pushed her against the wall, choked her with his hands around her neck and then slapped her three times.

    ?That was something I had never experienced before,? DeCoutere said. She left his house shortly after that in a taxi. ?It did not escalate; it stopped,? she said.

    In addition to her work as an actor, DeCoutere is a captain in the air force and a training development officer, ensuring that people in the service are receiving appropriate training.

    What follows are seven more cases that, including DeCoutere?s allegations, bring to eight the total number of women who have come forward with stories of abuse. Of these eight stories, four were included in the Star?s original story published on Monday. Four of the women have come forward this week.

    Ghomeshi, in a Facebook posting Sunday evening, wrote in an emotional statement that he has ?done nothing wrong.? He said it is not unusual for him to engage in ?adventurous forms of sex that included role-play, dominance and submission.? However, he said it has always been consensual. His lawyers echoed this in the statement of claim filed as part of his lawsuit.

    In his posting, Ghomeshi writes: ?Let me be the first to say that my tastes in the bedroom may not be palatable to some folks. They may be strange, enticing, weird, normal, or outright offensive to others. . . . But that is my private life. . . . And no one, and certainly no employer, should have dominion over what people do consensually in their private life.?

  • In 2002, Ghomeshi, then 35, was the host of Play , a culture and arts television show on CBC Newsworld. He struck up a conversation with a woman who was roughly his age and invited her to a taping of the show. The first time she came to the taping at CBC headquarters, they ended the evening at a local pub and then he drove her to her car. She alleges that as soon as they were in the car Ghomeshi reached over to the passenger seat, grabbed her hair and ?yanked it hard.?

    ?I was completely shocked,? she said. ?He asked if I like it rough. Quite honestly I don?t remember what I said. I was so shocked.?

    Though she regrets it now, she returned to a taping of the show two weeks later. He asked her to his home in Riverdale. Once there, she alleges that without consent he grabbed her hair and pulled her down to the floor. Then, she alleges, he delivered three sharp punches to the side of her head while she lay on the floor.

    ?I was crying. Just crying. He stood there looking at me and said, ?You should leave.? ? The woman said she called a taxi and left the home.

    The CBC program As it Happens also interviewed this woman and broadcast an account of her allegations Wednesday.

  • In 2005, Ghomeshi, then 38, was at a Toronto music and dance event in a park in Toronto. He ran into a woman he knew from the arts and culture scene. The woman, 34, had gone on a few dates with Ghomeshi but they had never been intimate. They went for a walk when the event was over and, according to the woman, Ghomeshi attacked her while they were sitting on a bench. He began kissing her forcefully and then ?put his hands around my neck and choked me.?

    ?He smothered me,? she said. She alleges Ghomeshi then grabbed her arms hard and ?bit? her, then pushed her down on the park bench and ?groped? her.

    ?I pushed him away. It really scared me. He was so aggressive,? the woman said. The next day, she said Ghomeshi contacted her and ?acted like nothing had happened.?

    ?There was absolutely nothing consensual about what happened to me,? the woman said.

  • A CBC employee in her late 20s alleges that in 2007 Ghomeshi was sitting with her and other producers at a story meeting for his radio show Q . After their colleagues stood up and left, she alleges Ghomeshi leaned in close to her and quietly said ?I want to hate f--- you?.

    Later, as the two were walking in to the Q studio, she alleges he laughed to her and quietly said, ?Wasn?t that funny when I told you I wanted to grudge f--- you??

    Three years later, she alleges that on his way out of the Q studio, Ghomeshi approached her from behind and cupped her buttocks.

    The woman later complained about Ghomeshi to her union representative at the CBC, who told her he reported her complaints to a CBC manager and to the executive producer of Q . She did not file a formal grievance.

    She says she was called to a meeting with Q ?s executive producer to discuss her complaints, whom she says asked her ?what (she) could do to make this a less toxic work environment??

    To her knowledge, Ghomeshi was never reprimanded for the incidents.

    The CBC announced Tuesday that in the wake of a Toronto Star story describing this woman?s allegations it has launched an investigation.

  • In 2012, a CBC producer in her mid-20s attended a book signing by Ghomeshi in Montreal. She waited in line to have her book signed, and once standing in front of Ghomeshi, she recalls telling him that her dream was to work on his radio show, Q . He asked her if she would like to join him and his friends for drinks after the event, she says. She agreed, and later remembers meeting him at the lobby of the Opus Hotel, where he was staying. He arrived alone and embraced her, she says.

    ?This isn?t a professional meeting,? she recalls Ghomeshi saying to her on the way to McKibbins Irish Pub. Seated in a booth, she says he rubbed her legs with both hands, explaining, ?I have anxiety. Touching helps.?

    ?The two worlds can co-exist,? she alleges he told her. ?I?ve done it before.?

    She remembers telling Ghomeshi, ?I want to work for you, not date you.? She said Ghomeshi kept complaining that his eyes were dry and he had to get his contact lenses out.

    They left the pub and went to Tim Hortons, where Ghomeshi bought a panini and later invited her to his hotel room, saying he had to take his contact lenses out.

    ?I feel like a big moron now,? said the woman, who is no longer with the CBC. ?I should have seen it coming.?

    In the hotel room, she recalls going to the bathroom and, as she was leaving it, discovering the lights were dimmed.

    She alleges Ghomeshi roughly threw her against the wall and kissed and fondled her forcefully. She states that she then performed fellatio on Ghomeshi ?just to get out of there.?

    ?I was saying to him, ?I don?t want to do this, I want to work for you.?

    As she was leaving the room crying, she says, she heard Ghomeshi say, ?I?ll talk with my executive producer about you.?

    The next morning she received a text from Ghomeshi. ?Happy Thursday,? it read. She was shocked.

    She says she did receive an invitation to a job interview from Ghomeshi?s executive producer shortly thereafter. In Toronto, she recalls, she was surprised to find Ghomeshi present at the interview.

    Immediately after she left the CBC building, she says Ghomeshi texted her to say that she looked sexier than ever in the interview, and he invited her out that night for drinks.

    She declined.

    ?I feel gross about the whole thing. I feel used,? the woman said.

  • In 2012, a fan of Ghomeshi?s in her mid-20s came to his book event in a small city in Eastern Canada. She stood in line to get her copy of his memoir signed, and she recalls him being overwhelmingly friendly, asking her name and many questions about herself. The next day, she received a private Facebook message from him containing his phone number and an invitation to call him.

    The two corresponded online, and Ghomeshi allegedly introduced violent sexualized language into their conversation, assuring her it was all fantasy and encouraging her to participate through email, which she did. She says he invited her to visit him in Toronto. She came, she says, but wouldn?t stay at his house. They went out for dinner, then back to a dorm at the University of Toronto where she was staying in the room of a friend who was out of town.

    She alleges that in the stairwell, Ghomeshi slammed her against a cement wall and she dropped her belongings. When she knelt to pick them up, he choked her from behind and struck her across the head. He demanded that she stand, and he marched her up the stairs into her friend?s empty dorm room.

    She says he demanded that she kneel, then hit her repeatedly about the head while she stared up in shock. She asked him about bruising, and he laughed and replied that he knew how to hit her so there wouldn?t be any. He hit her again, and she stared in disbelief and shock. She remembers feeling that he then lost interest and left, hugging her on his way out of the building. She later sent him an accusatory email, and he responded by email. The Star has copies of the correspondence.

    ?it IS about sex,? wrote Ghomeshi in an email to the woman, asserting that she had consented, ?it WAS. . . that you?ve decided to turn this ugly is disappointing. i wish for good karma into 2013.?

  • Also in 2012, another fan of Ghomeshi?s, also in her mid-20s, went to his book event in a small city in Eastern Canada. She stood in line to get her copy of his memoir signed, and when she stood before him, she recalls him asking her name and many questions about herself. She recalls that he wrote down details on a Post-it note, and later that evening he found her on Facebook and sent her his phone number and an invitation to get in touch. She did, and says she and Ghomeshi had dinner that evening, kissed and parted. They corresponded, and Ghomeshi allegedly introduced violent sexualized language into their conversation, assuring her when she failed to respond that it was all fantasy and encouraging her to participate, which she did. She recalls him assuring her these things would not happen in real life.

    Ghomeshi invited her to visit him in Toronto at his house in Cabbagetown, she says, and she did.

    When she arrived at his house and greeted him, she says Ghomeshi answered the door and stared at her. Without speaking, she alleges that he threw her against the wall and demanded that she get on her knees and perform fellatio. She alleges that when she kneeled down he struck her repeatedly about the head, ?hard enough that (her) vision was blurred.?

    She says he took his belt off, tied it tight around her neck, ?yanked? it, and led her around by the belt. They had intercourse, she said, and during it she alleges he whipped her back with his belt and hit her about the head. She alleges he put his full body weight on her face during fellatio, to the point where she gagged, couldn?t breathe, and felt she would vomit. A subsequent encounter, she alleges, left her with deep bruising on her body.

    She alleges that when she later confronted Ghomeshi and showed him pictures of her bruising, he told her that he found her bruises to be ?hot.?

    The woman told the Star that during this visit to his house she noticed he had a teddy bear in his room. She said he turned the teddy bear around so that the bear was facing away from them.

  • Last year, in 2013, a woman in her mid-20s says she had been on a few dates with Jian, but they never had sex. After they had been out of touch for weeks, she recalls Ghomeshi inviting her to his new house in Toronto?s Beach area because he ?needed? to see her to discuss something important. When she arrived, she says Ghomeshi sat her down for an intimate conversation. She says he told her that she might be ?the one? for him, that he ?didn?t buy this big house to throw parties, but to raise a family.?

    He then kissed her, she says, and while kissing he ?pulled (her) hair so hard my neck flew backward, and when it did,? she alleges, ?he smacked me.? She objected and asked why he did this. He laughed, she says, and explained to her that in order for him to build a future with her, he would need to see if they were sexually compatible, and she would have to ?let (him) enjoy this the way (he) wants to.? She says that he then turned his teddy bear around on his bed, telling her the bear ?shouldn?t see this.?

    Ghomeshi began kissing her again, she says, and struck her in the face once more, harder than before. He pointed out his erection, she says, as proof that she was ?the one? for him. He then allegedly demanded she kneel in a constrained position, allegedly grabbed her by the neck and hit her in the face hard, and allegedly engaged her in fellatio, forcefully. She says Ghomeshi bit her, leaving marks on her breasts, inner thighs and back. Later, Ghomeshi called her a degrading term. She objected, she says, and told him, ?don?t talk to me like that.?

    She says Ghomeshi shrank away from her at that moment, sulking. ?You?re making me feel like a weirdo,? she recalls him saying. He then said, ?You need to go,? and left the room. She dressed and walked downstairs, where she found Ghomeshi on his couch, absorbed in his computer screen, checking Twitter. She left the house, she says. He did not say goodbye.

    Months later, she confronted him in an email, suggesting that details of his behaviour might go public. ?i?m shaking as I read this,? he responded, ?can we please talk??

    Kevin Donovan can be reached at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it '; document.write( '' ); document.write( addy_text89356 ); document.write( '<\/a>' ); //-->\n This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it or (416) 312-3503, @_kevindonovan. Jesse Brown can be reached at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it

  • ?It?s Tory?s move?: Council's left to give Toronto?s new mayor a chance

    Rob Ford was elected mayor four years ago on a promise to take a sledgehammer to city council, its transit plans, and its budget. Immediately after he won, council’s left wing began trying to figure out how to thwart his agenda.

    John Tory was elected mayor Monday on a promise to bring council together. He will get a grace period.

    Tory, a moderate conservative, will be granted an opportunity to be the consensus-building pragmatist he said he would be, progressive councillors said in interviews Wednesday.

    “We have to give him a chance. We have to give his staff a chance,” said Paula Fletcher (Ward 30, Toronto-Danforth). “I think council has proved that it wants a balanced approach in the city of Toronto. A steady, balanced approach. And I’ll certainly give him a chance to make sure that that’s what he’s going to do. That’s just what I think people want in the city.”

    Tory did not release a formal platform, and several of his promises were unspecific. One progressive councillor, who asked for anonymity to candidly discuss strategy, said Tory has such a vague mandate — “I’m not Rob Ford, we’ll all get along, I’m not going to increases taxes past inflation, and I’m going to build SmartTrack someday” — that he has left an “awful lot of room for conversation” with the left.

    “It’s Tory’s move,” the councillor said. “By the end of January, it should be clear what kind of administration he wants to run. And we’ll govern ourselves accordingly.”

    Tory’s honeymoon may not be mere post-election courtesy. Maria Augimeri, a suburban progressive Tory supported in the election, said he will receive more votes on some issues from progressives than from conservatives.

    “This is a pro-housing guy. This is a pro-transit guy,” said Augimeri (Ward 9, York Centre).

    Augimeri said she expects Tory to operate in the inclusive manner of Mel Lastman, to whom he was an informal advisor. Lastman, another conservative, created positions to suit the passions of several progressives: Jack Layton was made homelessness advocate, Olivia Chow children’s advocate, Joe Pantalone tree advocate.

    “Every progressive had a leadership role. I envision that John Tory’s administration would be similar to that,” Augimeri said.

    Councillor Mike Layton, Jack’s son, said he would keep an “open mind” about the man who defeated his stepmother, Chow, two days ago.

    “I think we’ll have to see how Mr. Tory approaches this,” said Layton (Ward 19, Trinity-Spadina). “Certainly, my door will be always open. I’m waiting for his call to see when he wants to sit down to talk about how we can make the city a better place.”

    The informal left-wing bloc, which has about 15 solid members, meets every month. There are 44 councillors in all.

    Tory is likely to be opposed by most progressives on his effort to outsource garbage collection east of Yonge St. He would face a stiff fight if he took any steps toward cancelling the Sheppard and Finch LRTs, as some area councillors want.

    His proposal to pay for SmartTrack through tax increment financing has been questioned by councillors of all stripes. And he will have to finesse the tricky issue of the downtown relief line, a priority for many progressives that he believes is less important than SmartTrack.

    For now, though, there are no battles at all. Fletcher praised even the Tory caution that got him mocked as a waffler by both of his election rivals.

    “The fact that he said he’s waiting for the staff report on island airport expansion, waiting for the staff report for the Gardiner, are all good signs,” Fletcher said. “He’s not coming in with his mind simply made up, my way or the highway. And that’s a relief.”

  • Commons guards rebuffed in demand for weapons

    OTTAWA—A year before a gunman stormed the front doors of Parliament, the House of Commons rejected demands from its guards to be armed while on duty outside, telling them instead to “retreat” from any crisis.

    The 2013 demand from the union representing Commons security staff related to the times when guards were working on the grounds of Parliament Hill, assisting RCMP officers at frequent rallies and protests.

    The Commons guards work alongside Mounties to help identify MPs and get the politicians through security lines during events that bring large crowds to Parliament Hill.

    But the Security Service Employees Association complained that the Commons administration was not providing employees with the tools needed to do the task safely.

    The association wanted the unarmed Commons’ constables to be provided with a firearm to ensure they are ready to react in the event of a security crisis.

    But in a reply to the association, Commons’ clerk Audrey O’Brien rejected the guards’ concerns saying that outside, at least, the security officials were only in place to support the RCMP.

    And because of that, she laid out an explicit demand that Commons guards not get involved in any security situation that happens outside.

    “House of Commons constables are not to respond to a security crisis should one occur; they are requested to retreat and let the RCMP manage the situation,” O’Brien wrote in an Oct. 28, 2013 letter.

    She said that “adequate” precautionary measures had been taken by the employer and RCMP and that Commons guards “do not need to be armed in order to safely perform visual identification.”

    Asked for comment on Wednesday, Heather Bradley, spokesperson for Commons Speaker Andrew Scheer, said the context of the association’s complaint “should be made clear.”

    “This matter related to House of Commons Security Services personnel on the grounds outside the parliament buildings, which is under the exclusive jurisdiction of the RCMP,” Bradley told the Star.

    She said the demand did not relate to the arming of Commons personnel inside the buildings. And Bradley said Commons security guards are responsible for handling a crisis situation that happens inside the building, a point driven home by last week’s attack.

    Still, there have been serious questions raised about security on the Hill after Michael Zehaf-Bibeau barged through the main doors of Centre Block carrying a .30-30 Winchester rifle, past two unarmed, uniformed Commons guards.

    And the brazen attack has put a spotlight on the jurisdictions that see four separate security agencies have a hand in protecting Parliament Hill.

    At the time of the Oct. 22 attack, only plainclothes Commons security staff were armed, meaning the two uniformed guards at the front entrance of Centre Block had no weapons.

    Zehaf-Bibeau had just shot and killed Cpl. Nathan Cirillo, who was standing sentry duty at the nearby National War Memorial, when he crossed to Parliament Hill.

    As Zehaf-Bibeau entered the main entrance of Centre Block, Const. Samearn Son grabbed at the rifle barrel and yelled out an alert to other guards. In the tussle, the rifle discharged, wounding Son in the leg.

    Zehaf-Bibeau continued down the main hall, where it’s believed he was wounded by a plainclothes Commons security guard before being killed in a round of gunfire led by Sergeant-at-Arms Kevin Vickers.

    In the wake of the unprecedented attack, Scheer has launched several reviews of security procedures but the Commons administration has moved quickly with several changes to boost security.

    Since Monday, some uniformed Commons guards have begun carrying sidearms, adding firepower to the already armed plainclothes officers also on duty. The number of armed uniformed guards is expected to grow over the coming weeks as more and more are trained in the use of firearms.

    Senate guards — authorized in June to carry firearms — will be armed once they are trained.

    And armed RCMP officers, who until the attack had jurisdiction to guard the prime minister outside the Parliament buildings, now accompany him inside as well.

Arts & Letters
Sunday, 12 August 2007